Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Steve Martin's avatar

Hi Laura.

This article is a fascinating mix of culture and science!

I couldn't help but to recall that some ingestable anti-aging supplements sold on television here in Japan are openly marketed as derived from placenta. I feel slightly queasy when one such commercial pops up, complete with paid youthful-looking elderly actors touting the products. As a linguist, I chalked up my unease to the typical Japanese consumer not being familiar with the 'exotic' non-Japanese medical term 'placenta' used in the marketing. That being said, I had no idea of any studies regarding real health benefits. As I've slowly found out with loss of fluid in my knee, so much snake oil is being aimed at one of the world's fastest aging populations.

Out of curiosity, I ran a Perplexity Pro search for the names of those consumer items and came up with the following ...

"Several Japanese supplements containing placenta and using the word in their product names are available on the market. Here are some notable examples:

Dr. Select Placenta Drink 300000: A beauty drink containing placenta extract, collagen, and other ingredients to promote beauty and health.

Beauty Miracle Placenta: A capsule supplement containing pig placenta extract, fish collagen, hyaluronic acid, and other beauty-enhancing ingredients.

Placenta C Jelly: A jelly-type supplement containing placenta extract, collagen, and various beauty ingredients, available in 31-bottle packs for a month's supply.

Metabolic The Placenta Premium: A dietary supplement in capsule form, containing placenta, collagen, hyaluronic acid, elastin, and royal jelly.

DHC Pure Fresh Placenta: A supplement made from domestic placenta, designed to be easily absorbed.

Maruman PLACENTA Premium: A supplement containing placenta extract, various vitamins, and biologically active substances.

Royal Jelly with Placenta: A capsule supplement combining fermented placenta and royal jelly.

These products demonstrate the popularity of placenta-based supplements in the Japanese market, with many emphasizing beauty, anti-aging, and health benefits."

Another query response said, "It's important to note that many health authorities, including Health Canada and the FDA, have not authorized human placenta products for consumption due to potential health risks. The use of human-derived ingredients in cosmetics is also prohibited in the European Union due to concerns about disease transmission".

The FDA? Or snake-oil salesmen? I feel like I'm caught between the devil and the deep blue sea. Thanks for pointing to one sane direction of research.

Cheers Laura.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts